A Literary Journal for New & Established Voices

Cookie Surprise

by | Oct 27, 2026 | Fiction | 1 comment

by Rachel Hollis

Our studio apartment smelled like damp carpet and wet pennies. Mom’s hair was box-dye red, clashing with everything. For special occasions, she dipped a Hershey’s bar in milk and rolled it in crushed vanilla wafers. She called it Cookie Surprise. The first time, I asked her why we couldn’t just have cake. She went still, eyes foggy.

“This is what we can do,” she said, turning back to the sink.

So I ate it, smiled wide and told her it was better than cake. It wasn’t. Even at five, the lie sat heavy on my tongue.

For years, Mom made Cookie Surprise. Even after she met Ted and he moved us to the suburbs. Even after I got a job at Safeway and could take home day-old cake for free. Even after the settlement check for the soggy carpets that bred black mold. I still told her it was my favorite.

On my twenty-first birthday, I came down the stairs to our whole family singing. Mom beamed over a plate of half-melted chocolate, milk, and stale cookies, dotted with too many candles. We all ate it for breakfast, like we hadn’t spent years pretending—except Ted. Diabetes. I almost envied him.

When Ted died, Mom started flushing strange things down the toilet. Underwear. Coins. Her wedding ring. Anything she wanted to hide. After the plumber came a third time, he suggested we find her a facility. She stared at the floor. Her bright hair had long since faded. “Will they have a toilet there?”

The morning we moved her in, we ate in the shared dining hall. At the end, a staff member came by with a tray of cake slices, dark ganache shimmering under fluorescent lights.

“None for me,” I said.

Mom nodded. “Julie doesn’t like cake.”

Image by Ray Suarez via Pexels

About the Author

1 Comment

  1. Sherri A.

    What a poignant story without sentiment and beautifully described. Amazing how so few words, well-written, can evoke such feeling.

    Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.